The Complex Web of Race and Representation in ‘Game of Thrones: House of the Dragon’

The Complex Web of Race and Representation in ‘Game of Thrones: House of the Dragon’

r r

The casting choices and representation in the fantasy series ‘Game of Thrones: House of the Dragon’ have sparked significant discussion regarding race and character portrayal. Critics argue that while the show has included Black actors in traditionally white roles, it has failed to adequately develop their characters or address their racial identities within the narrative context.

r r

Color-Conscious Casting and Racial Themes

r r

One key point raised is the concept of color-conscious casting, where Black actors are cast in roles originally written for white characters. Critics contend that this approach serves as a superficial diversity measure without meaningful integration of racial themes into the storyline.

r r

For instance, the character Corlys Velaryon, played by Steve Toussaint, is a prominent Black character. However, the show does not explore the implications of his race within the plot effectively, rendering the character's racial identity invisible. This has led to a critique that the series is engaging in a form of performance diversity rather than substantive exploration of racial themes.

r r

Misrepresentation and Narrative Choices

r r

The narrative choices have led to a portrayal of the Velaryon family that some viewers find problematic. The storyline involves a paternity scandal where the legitimacy of Rhaenyra Targaryen's children is questioned, despite them being depicted as having white features. This has raised concerns about the implication of race and ancestry within the narrative and whether the parallel to real-world racism is being addressed or simply glossed over.

r r

Screen Time and Character Development

r r

Moreover, character development and screen time have been a significant issue for some viewers. For example, Amenys Velaryon, often referred to as the Prince of Tides, has not received sufficient screen time, despite the hints that he is about to become the Hand of the Queen. His character is seen as important, yet the show has downplayed his significance through limited appearances, leaving many fans questioning whether he is being given the attention he deserves.

r r

Similar concerns were raised regarding the significance of other characters, such as the Velaryon family, and how their racial identities and backstories are woven into the narrative. The depiction of the Velaryons as Black characters, while interesting, has been met with skepticism from some viewers who feel that their stories are underdeveloped and that the show is not providing the depth and context that would make their characters feel more authentic and integral to the story.

r r

Feudal Settings and Backstories

r r

The feudal settings of Game of Thrones and House of the Dragon often do not lend themselves to diverse casts. Medieval Europe, upon which the series is based, was not a multicultural world. This poses a challenge for world-building and representation. When characters of color are introduced, they need a believable back story to justify their presence in a predominantly white setting.

r r

The Velaryons’ backstory is somewhat plausible, as they are of Valyrian stock like the Targaryens but made their fortunes via sea trade on the empire’s periphery. However, for other characters, this back story can feel forced and contrived. Efforts to introduce diversity without a solid foundation can come across as lazy pandering to a vocal minority rather than authentic world-building.

r r

Conclusion

r r

Representing race in fantasy series is a complex and sensitive issue. While House of the Dragon takes steps to include Black actors in traditionally white roles, the efficacy of these choices remains a subject of debate. The series must strike a balance between diversity and substance, ensuring that racial themes are integrated meaningfully into the narrative and that characters of color are given the same level of development and attention as their white counterparts.

r r

Key Takeaways:

r r r Color-conscious casting: The casting of Black actors in traditionally white roles for the purposes of diversity.r Diversity in fantasy: The challenge of balancing diversity with substantive representation in a predominantly white, medieval setting.r Racial themes: The importance of integrating racial themes meaningfully into the narrative context.r r